Re: OT: was Re: and visual library once again



tmoran@xxxxxxx wrote:


There's a hidden assumption in that argument, namely that "GPL'd" is a
subset of "public goods". If GPL'd programs aren't public goods, then
your conclusion about who will pay programmers is invalid.

To not be a "Public Good", it would have to either be exclusive - easy to control who gets a copy, or rivalrous - if you have it, it will be less valuable to me (a CIA cryptography program for instance). Offhand I can't think of an example of GPLing such a program.

But I'm sure you *can* think of some examples of GPL'd programs, and those will then have to fall into the "public goods" category. Hence, by your own reasoning, GPL'd programs *are* (a subset of) public goods, which is perfectly consistent with your calling Steve's GPL'd programs public goods.


Further, I said "the market
will undersupply", not "the market will supply zero, so only non-market
orgs will supply".

True, but the sentence continued "leaving it to government or other organizations not guided by the market to pay programmers." That sounds like the market would not pay programmers to any significant extent.


--
Björn Persson                              PGP key A88682FD
                   omb jor ers @sv ge.
                   r o.b n.p son eri nu
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: and visual library once again
    ... economists: Only will pay programmers to produce public goods programs. ... There's a hidden assumption in that argument, namely that "GPL'd" is a subset of "public goods". ... If GPL'd programs aren't public goods, then your conclusion about who will pay programmers is invalid. ... apply to material objects, and try to use them on information such as ...
    (comp.lang.ada)
  • Re: WAY OT: Gas-Gouging Greenspan
    ... Those who think the market ... > can be replaced as the provider of public goods just do not understand ... That is not to say that some stuff now done by government ... be in reference to the highways, of which an abundance of alternatives would ...
    (alt.sports.football.pro.ne-patriots)
  • Re: Libertarian cartoons
    ... police services through market mechanisms. ... outside your building (and probably immediately call the government -- ... involves public goods, however, like the department of education, ... it's really a nail anyway and any belief system willing to entertain the ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Libertarian cartoons
    ... the market would have already done it. ... by now, and look, only Bill Snyder has it, and he knew Mike would give ... It's not so long once you take off the non- public goods. ... problems on national scales. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Libertarian cartoons
    ... plausible prose man wrote: ... market does not solve and has never been observed to solve. ... in a country with government run military and police has almost no ... involves public goods, however, like the department of education, ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)