Re: PAR (Was: Embedded languages based on early Ada)

If you can persuade programmers to use "par" unless they explicitly
*need* sequential execution, a great many statements will be marked
as concurrent. Numeric codes will use "par" in the computational
core, as well as outer layers of execution.
When "virtual memory" was new some programmers thought about their
program's access patterns and found that VM was a great simplification.
Other programmers simply said "oh, good, I can write my program to
randomly access many megabytes, though the physical memory is only
a few hundred kilobytes." Those programs were a disaster. Nowadays,
of course, very few people write programs that don't in fact fit inside
physical memory. I suspect we'll see a similar thing with multi-core:
some will carefully consider what they are doing and it will be good;
others will just say "oh, good, I can multiply an m x n and an n x p
matrix using m x p threads", and it will be bad. Meanwhile the
hardware will develop to automatically do more and more hidden
concurrency. If programmers think of "par" as "I've carefully analyzed
this algorithm and it may be run in parallel" that's good. If they
think of "par" as "I want you to run this in parallel", I think that
would be a bad mindset. Explicit Ada tasks are more like the latter.
My $.02
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: First class developer: who ?
    ... high-quality code can write high-quality concurrent code, ... I'll agree that you probably don't want junior programmers writing your ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Adding a Par construct to Python?
    ... professional programmers to grasp. ... dependencies before swapping 'par' for 'for', ... Pardon my cynicism but sync would appear to have all the disadvantages ... Actually the 'sync' command could lead to deadlock potentially: ...
    (comp.lang.python)
  • Re: Adding a Par construct to Python?
    ... The reason ... programmers to exploit natural parallelism in their algorithms. ... you want par to be utterly simple-minded and to do no ... can't just replace a for loop with a par loop in the general case. ...
    (comp.lang.python)
  • Re: First class developer: who ?
    ... high-quality code can write high-quality concurrent code, ... I'll agree that you probably don't want junior programmers writing your ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Adding a Par construct to Python?
    ... 'par' makes sense as an official Python construct - we already have had ... programmers to exploit natural parallelism in their algorithms. ... you want par to be utterly simple-minded and to do no ... to worry about those complications. ...
    (comp.lang.python)