Re: What makes a good C/C++ programmer?

From: Gianni Mariani (gi2nospam_at_mariani.ws)
Date: 01/24/05 

Date: Sun, 23 Jan 2005 21:12:27 -0800

E. Robert Tisdale wrote:
> Gianni Mariani wrote:
...
>
>
> After removing superfluous semicolons after namespace definitions,
>
> austria-0.8/job> g++ -Wall -Wno-long-long -ansi -pedantic \
> -I../src/austria/code -L../src/austria/code/work.gx86 \
> -o main main.cc -laustria
> austria-0.8/job> ./main
> M::Do(void)
>
> it compiles and runs without complaint.
> You need to explain an "Austria C++ smart pointer".
> An astute candidate would *not* assume that it has the usual meaning.
> But, if it has the usual meaning
> and the candidate is familiar with smart pointers,
> then you should expect the candidate to spot the error immediately.

Yep. This is a design issue. This should be somthing that someone with
experience should pick up.

>
> I would say this *is* a good question
> because the programmer cannot depend upon the compiler or testing
> to reveal the bug. Of course,
> we would expect that this bug would manifest itself eventually.
>
> Evidently, smart pointers are important to you
> and you should make sure that your programmers understand them.
> But smart pointers are *not* a difficult concept to grasp
> so any deficiency in understanding them is easily corrected
> and I don't think that this question would do very much
> to help you decide which candidate is the better C++ programmer.

You're right. Smart pointers are somthing that could be picked up
quickly. The point is that the questions were pre-interview, the "take
as long as you like to answer them" type and so if someone decided to,
they could find out with about 5 minutes of google and reading (if not
less).

Relevant Pages

  • Re: What makes a good C/C++ programmer?
    ... > it compiles and runs without complaint. ... > and the candidate is familiar with smart pointers, ... > because the programmer cannot depend upon the compiler or testing ... > we would expect that this bug would manifest itself eventually. ...
    (comp.lang.cpp)
  • Re: What makes a good C/C++ programmer?
    ... it compiles and runs without complaint. ... smart pointers are important to you ... to help you decide which candidate is the better C++ programmer. ...
    (comp.lang.cpp)
  • Re: What makes a good C/C++ programmer?
    ... it compiles and runs without complaint. ... smart pointers are important to you ... to help you decide which candidate is the better C++ programmer. ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Re: VS2005 major development bug
    ... Which Bug, haven't found one in your example only an access exception? ... If you had used the project which was in the .zip file you would have seen that it was compiled with Managed C++ and not C++/CLI, and that it compiles fine. ... To get detailed information by the compiler define your "pimpl" class outside the form. ... The pimpl class is a nested class of my ref class so that it can access all of the members of my ref class ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.vc)
  • Re: Speed advantage of language written in itself?
    ... Bug source reduction: Once the implementation runs or compiles ... causing problems in yours. ... component of its own test suite. ...
    (comp.lang.lisp)