Re: [OT] Of Java and C#


"Charles Hottel" <chottel@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:Fgpvh.18407$w91.16217@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"Pete Dashwood" <dashwood@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:5223m8F1mdkagU1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<snip>

So Pete how would you compare C# and Java? do you like C# better or is it
primarily the IDE?


I prefer C#.

But it is silly to get emotional about programming languages...:-)

Java works well with Eclipse and this was the platform for the last
commercial team I managed. Eclipse is also a good IDE but, for me, the
DotNET framework is the clincher. You CAN use it from Java but C# is
designed to work with it and I have been very impressed with how easy it is
to do things in C#. Tasks that used to take days to research, code, debug,
and finally get working now get done in minutes. The online support is
phenomenal and I have used the video tutorials to good advantage. The
organizaion of the Help for C# is MUCH better than I have found with any
other langauage. You can find what you need in minutes and so far, I have
never been disappointed when looking for help.

I'm not sorry I spent time learning Java; it helped me immensely to
understand OO COBOL and the OO grounding you get in learning Java is
excellent.

As I get more into C# I find it quite fascinating. It seems to be a very
good compromise between Java and C++.

It has a fundamental simplicity and elegance which I find very appealing,
and it borrows the good points of Java anyway...

Visual Studio is simply excellent and I think it would enhance any language
you used it with. Fujitsu DotNET COBOL uses it, and I'm sure COBOL can be
written much faster and more accurately with its support. Once you start
using it, you realise that this is the kind of tool programmers SHOULD have
had years ago...

I am now looking forward to using C# to turn my desktop application into a
Web Service. The last time I built a Web Service was several years ago and
it involved using DCOM + and wrapping it in a SOAP layer for transport. It
took me several weeks of full on hard work, reading about it (when I could
find anything about it, and trying to fill in the blanks when I couldn't)
and it was a painful process trying to test it. It finally worked, but it
was a full month of real pain.

I don't think it will be so bad this time...

Pete.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Java-Rauschen (war: Re: Getter & Setter)
    ... also stimmst du mir zu dass Java ohne IDE schlecht nutzbar ist? ... Nun mal abgesehen dass man APIs nicht mehr lernt, sondern sich einfach auf Codecompletion verlässt und dabei Hilfsklassen vollkommen ignoriert, ... Oder wenn der Grad des Rauschen so unterschiedlich ist? ...
    (de.comp.lang.java)
  • Re: Java-Rauschen (war: Re: Getter & Setter)
    ... welche Perspektive hatten denn die Leute, die Java entworfen haben? ... Aber gehe ich recht in der Annahme dass du dann sagst, dass Java erst durch eine IDE "richtig gut" wird?... ... Ich sehe es allerdings für eine textbasierte Programmiersprache als Nachteil an, wenn sie aufgrund der "Umständlichkeit" der Sprache ohne IDE kaum nutzbar ist. ...
    (de.comp.lang.java)
  • Java-Rauschen (war: Re: Getter & Setter)
    ... aber bei HTML ist nicht so sehr der Source als viel mehr das was im Browser angezeigt wird wichtig. ... Ich finde, eine interessantere Frage ist, warum man ueberhaupt gegen eine IDE ist. ... Nur hängt das mit einer bestimmten Menge an Code zusammen und die erreicht man bei Java schneller als bei zum Beispiel Ruby. ... Ich sehe es allerdings für eine textbasierte Programmiersprache als Nachteil an, wenn sie aufgrund der "Umständlichkeit" der Sprache ohne IDE kaum nutzbar ist. ...
    (de.comp.lang.java)
  • Re: Java-Rauschen (war: Re: Getter & Setter)
    ... Programmieren meinst, dass die IDE doch eh die ganze Zeit läuft, dann ... Eclipse ... Wenn du jetzt sagen würdest ich bin Java gegenüber Voreingenommen ... Groovy Java *braucht*, stört dich hingegen nicht. ...
    (de.comp.lang.java)
  • Re: recommendations or a java development environment
    ... does anyone have any recommendations for a java ... BemusedbyQM> development environment? ... to become lazy and let an IDE flag your errors, ...
    (comp.lang.java.help)