Re: Idle Thoughts

Bob Dawson wrote:
> "Jarle Stabell" wrote
>
>> What is meant by the expression: 1/infinity ?
>
> An infinitesimal. Let's call it the hypothetical last element of the
> infinite set [1/1,1/2,1/3,...].

Since that set/sequence *doesn't* contain a smallest/last element, I'm not
able to understand that definition. :-)

>
> Or in more practical terms, the value of x in the expression
>
> 1 - 0.999... = x

In standard mathematics, x = 0.

Do you have experience using non-standard analysis?

I've been told that some school (I think it was in Denmark) experimented
with letting students learn non-standard analysis instead of standard
(ordinary) analysis. In non-standard analysis, infinitely large and small
numbers "exists". If you use non-standard numbers in intermediate
calculations, but end up with a result not mentioning these "non-standard
numbers", there's a theorem of mathematical logic stating that the result
will hold true also in standard analysis. (Which is why it can be useful to
"temporarily" use these non-standard numbers).
I don't know how the experiments went, but I suppose that even though
non-standard techniques can simplify some tasks, it probably brought the
students problems when encountering "ordinary" mathematics.

Cheers,
Jarle


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Formulating sentences in a possibly consistent ZF
    ... communist countries the standard color is red, so any non-standard ... philosophy, that people often feel free to bandy about abstract ... as we regard the business of philosophy of mathematics as being ...
    (sci.logic)
  • Re: Solving the Tony Orlow mystery (part 1 of ?)
    ... > one of his recent replies) that TO's integers are non-standard ones, ... > infinitesimals) don't form a (standard) set either) To avoid apparent ... > version of non-standard analysis, admit that TO's integers are the real ... > ZF(but I will use, of course, infinite sets myself) ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: how to list all of the real numbers
    ... who work primarily in classical mathematics, ... they are not regarded as being standard theories at all. ... Non-standard analysis, in its model theoretic form, is a result ... Cranks barely have a coherent understanding of the ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Non-standard arithmetic
    ... to all intuition -- every property of all standard naturals ... automatically carries over to all non-standard naturlals. ... (with additional axioms to define/distinguish standard and non- ...
    (sci.logic)
  • Re: IE8 got me too :-( Sorry Jeff.
    ... with all the non-standard web browsers, ... What does it cost when they can't read your page with their browser ... Standard compliant code in general can be read by more people. ... Ever see all the non-standard stuff ...
    (comp.os.vms)