Theme colors in the Vista era



Just out of Vista preview session, someone noticed that MS apps in Vista didn't care about theme colors much, and after testing, that proved to be actually the case: most have their own hard-coded color sets, and no amount of tinkering with the theme colors or appearance settings seems to affect them.

This follows a trend started by Office 2003, and its flashy colors which ignored the theme (leading to very ugly results for out of the ordinary themes).

So far, when doing gradients or themed bitmaps, we tried here to stick to variations of the theme colors (darkening, lightening, hue shifts, etc.) rather than handpick and impose/hardcode colors. Worked fine enough in XP, but the result is that in Vista, this just gives "the old look", the default theme colors being quite bland compared to the flashy colors of the vista explorer f.i. But ignore clBtnFace and the rest, handpick a few vista flashy colors, and the same gradients suddenly fit the rest of the vista UI.

Built-in controls are themed and okay, sure, but for all the custom ones? or all the cosmetic stuff around controls? Are applications now supposed to coordinate their own look, and damn-the-user-theme... like Office did? like websites do?
Or is this just a limitation of the RC1?

Eric
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Legacy 6.0 and MS Vista
    ... Running a Hauppauge WinTV. ... FWIW I had to get a vista machine at work to do support work with and I have found it to be the worst operating system I've ever used. ... have you tried turning off aero or changing your theme colors to see if that has any effect on the problem. ... We can't seem to see differences when comparing system or application settings. ...
    (soc.genealogy.computing)
  • Re: Legacy 6.0 and MS Vista
    ... Running a Hauppauge WinTV. ... FWIW I had to get a vista machine at work to do support work with and I have found it to be the worst operating system I've ever used. ... have you tried turning off aero or changing your theme colors to see if that has any effect on the problem. ... We can't seem to see differences when comparing system or application settings. ...
    (soc.genealogy.computing)
  • Re: Gartner: Everything in Vista is based on .Net, ... ;)
    ... Initial feedback on Vista's graphical features around here is much less positive now than it was during the earlier betas. ... We had several Vista early adopters amongst our customers and internally, but quite a few have reverted to XP because of the "annoying graphic animations". ... Having stuff popup and react with animations, or be painted with flashy colors looked very neat to them initially, but it got qualified as "headache inducing" after working with them for whole days and weeks. ...
    (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)