Re: Altium Protel?



Eric wrote:
> Hello All,
>
> My company currently uses Altium's PCAD 2004 and are considering
> switching to Altium Protel 2004.
>
> For the people using Protel, how do you like it?
>

We use the Altium DXP (which is the latest version of the Protel
software) schematic package at work. It is the worst schematic package
I have ever used. It is buggy and has a lousy user interface. I have
used many schematic packages over that past years and I am constantly
amazed at how Altium can make the simplest things so complicated.

- Simple features like dragging sections of schematic never works
properly. It insists on adding connections between wires that weren't
there before.

- Clicking on Undo after a drag and drop causes the program to crash

- The Help files are useless. It has never had any help information on
anything I have tried to look up.

- There is no easy way to specify that you want to have seperate ground
planes that connect a single point.

- The print function is hopelessly complicated (There are 3 different
Print Menu fuctions and settings from one conflict with settings from
others).

The list of problems goes on and on....

I think that DXP is an overpriced, underperforming piece of software. I
think that the programmers who wrote it should be sentenced to a year
of doing 'real' designs with it for an electrical engineer and then see
how they like it.

Other than that, I think it sucks.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Gerber files
    ... ViewMate gives me an error 28: ... all the file extensions given by Protel can't be viewed. ... I have just outputted a complete series of Gerber files using Altium ...
    (sci.electronics.cad)
  • Re: schematics and PCB design software. whats best?
    ... Some free quality software? ... (Protel, DXP and such) ... I've worked with Altium and it just sucks! ... Just use the same as the Protel Autotrax software ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Protel 2004
    ... upgrade path to Protel 2004. ... I remember when Protel 98 first came out. ... stable performer but it was quite a while before it was available. ... What I'm saying is I don't trust Altium to deliver a satisfactory ...
    (sci.electronics.cad)
  • Re: Anyone have real world prices for PADS and Altium Designer PCB design apps?
    ... licensed users on this group of both PADs and Altium but they are probably ... all I know about Altium is what came up on a google search ... features and is much more complex than any earlier version of Protel. ... So it might appear that Altium is worse, but the bugs/feature ratio ...
    (sci.electronics.cad)