Re: MIL-STD-188-114A vs. RS-232



Al Clark wrote:
I did a product many years ago that supported MIL-STD-188-114A (I think).
As I recall the main difference was polarity. They had a few other slew
rate issues I think as well. I'm fairly sure that we just used 189 and 188
type devices anyway and we never had an issue interfacing anything.

A typical 232 driver has something like a 300 ohm series R. This is to
protect it from shorts. You could probably add some Q's then then use a
series R

Thanks Al. The polarity is not important as it is programmable in the
FPGA. I had considered adding a separate TTL -> 114A interface using
discrete transistors, but your suggestion makes it simpler. I can just
use a complementary pair, each device in an emitter follower
configuration. With a Vcc of +-5 volt, this will pull to better than
the 4 volt minimum and a 50 Ohm resistor will provide the current
limit. We already have a SOT-23 dual transistor that should do the
job. I will have to add a voltage inverter to generate -5 volts. That
may be more difficult since I need a true -5 volts. A capacitor
inverter circuit using diodes will not get a full -5 volts. I guess I
could use FETs, or maybe I can find a very small IC to do the job.
Space on the board is very tight though.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Is it possible to simulate ac signal with dc?..tia sal
    ... One has DC as any signal always of the same polarity, ... > consider a PWM signal from a small fraction of a volt to many volts). ... > Another argument I have seen rage from the PWM situation is whether a ... complete idiot, or some idiot with a phd attempting to think outside the box ...
    (sci.electronics.misc)
  • Re: Is it possible to simulate ac signal with dc?..tia sal
    ... DC with a varying voltage but always the same polarity can of course be ... consider a PWM signal from a small fraction of a volt to many volts). ... complete idiot, or some idiot with a phd attempting to think outside the box ... Modulating frequency which will vary in the range of 20 Hz. ...
    (sci.electronics.misc)
  • Re: Is it possible to simulate ac signal with dc?..tia sal
    ... DC with a varying voltage but always the same polarity can of course be ... consider a PWM signal from a small fraction of a volt to many volts). ... complete idiot, or some idiot with a phd attempting to think outside the box ...
    (sci.electronics.misc)
  • Re: Is it possible to simulate ac signal with dc?..tia sal
    ... DC with a varying voltage but always the same polarity can of course be ... consider a PWM signal from a small fraction of a volt to many volts). ... complete idiot, or some idiot with a phd attempting to think outside the box ... i.e. does the voltage of the centre pin of the phono connector stay above the ground connection or does the voltage alternate between say -1v and +1v. ...
    (sci.electronics.misc)