Re: GPS module good for timekeeping?

On Feb 12, 8:35 am, Rich Webb <bbew...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Wed, 11 Feb 2009 18:34:01 -0800 (PST), rickman <gnu...@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

This is a very interesting discussion to me.  I recently developed an
IRIG-B time code product and none of those problems occurred.  In
fact, I had originally put a several frame (1 per second) sync time in
the hardware taking a queue from what I have seen in comms protocols.
The customer wanted it to sync faster so on the network side of the
card it now syncs on the first detection of a frame marker and on the
IRIG-B side I it syncs on two complete frames.  The customer has
tested this for 72 hours with no sync slips.  Of course a time code is
a single stream of data combined with the detail timing reference.
The GPS signal seems to have two signals which are not well
correlated.

Neither the PPS signal nor the NMEA data streams are in any way part of
the GPS signal itself. A GPS receiver may choose to emit NMEA messages,
or Rockwell binary, or a military IDS, or a PPS but all of those are
generated by the receiver itself.

Yes, of course. I should have said "the signal from the GPS
module".

I also worked with a similar time code used in Military radios and it
also was a single stream combining the data (time value) with the 1
pps marker. We built a GPS unit to give the radio location info. I
don't know if they ever used the GPS module to provide time data. I
guess if they did they would have found this issue.


The time stamp on a NMEA message should reflect the time at which its
data fields were valid and will only be loosely correlated with UTC by
the time it gets queued and then sent out the serial port. Time of
receipt of, say, a $GPZDA sentence was never intended to be precisely
synchronized to UTC.

That sounds a lot like weasel wording. A GPS receiver does not have
the same sort of time and priority problems that a PC will have. If
they can't provide a few ms of messages in a timely manner, then the
product is defective. So I don't buy the idea that I should not
expect the messages to be sent in a timely manner. If there are other
issues involved... no, I don't think anyone has pointed out any issues
that are not *design* issues in the receiver. There is a 1 PPS signal
that is recovered from the GPS signal. This is coordinated to "real"
time to within microseconds according to all the docs I have read on
GPS receivers. The calculations are typically done on a 1 sec
interval. The receiver should be keeping a PLL for updating the time
data. Then the time output by the receiver can be closely correlated
to the 1 PPS signal. If they don't do this, then it is a design
issue, not an inherent flaw.

The timing of the sentences reporting time should be closely
correlated to the 1 PPS signal (which *IS* correlated to UTM) that it
can be matched to the correct 1 PPS pulse. Otherwise, what is the
point of the sentence?


I think when using time code signals of any type, it is important to
design the receiver as a PLL rather than as just a decoder.  So any
one message does not disrupt the timing.  Of course this requires more
complex design, but as Vladimir has found, simpler solutions have
problems.

Yup, absolutely true.

I just don't know how the GPS module makers implement their time
sentences. I know that my work with retail units show they have any
number of issues, but I guess that is to be expected. I bet the
$10,000 mil units don't have *any* of these problems. I don't know
how much the surveying units cost, but they are accurate enough to
locate a point to within a few cm. That's pretty durn amazing!

Rick
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: List of Cranks here
    ... > signal to reach the receiver due to multi paths ... > so GPS receivers are programmed to compute out the ... The GPS satellites broadcast on two carrier frequencies: ... > The Military can play games with the GPS signals by ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: List of Cranks here
    ... >> signal to reach the receiver due to multi paths ... >> so GPS receivers are programmed to compute out the ... >> The Military can play games with the GPS signals by ... > There are a dozen relativistic corrections incorporated in GPS ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Evidences for the ether
    ... |> | How does a GPS receiver determine it's position? ... | A GPS satellite emits its time together with data that make ... | A receiver receives this signal. ... and the time of the satellite clocks when the signals were sent. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Modern trains and electronic equipment?
    ... the already challenging environment (any train) you are sitting in: ... I suspect that sucessful GPS reception with an indoor antenna on board ... likely field strengths for which a receiver would have to operate, ... receiver and get it to receive marginal signals (with high error ...
    (uk.transport.london)
  • Re: NEW GPS with the best sensitivity of antenna!!!
    ... > I have head that under tree cover after rain GPS doesn't work. ... the geometry of the satellites being used with respect to receiver ... diffraction, ans scattering of the satellite signal by trees, utility ... Satellite clock--Errors in the transmitted clock, ...
    (sci.geo.satellite-nav)