Singletons
From: Calum Grant (calumg_at_no.onetel.spam.com)
Date: 01/15/05
- Next message: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Queries and OO"
- Previous message: JMF: "Re: Application, database and schema?"
- Next in thread: Daniel T.: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Daniel T.: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: smilemac: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Andrew McDonagh: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: H. S. Lahman: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Thomas Gagne: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Thomas Gagne: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Roger L. Cauvin: "Re: Singletons"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
Date: Sat, 15 Jan 2005 15:17:35 GMT
I quite often see singletons in code, and I think they are overused.
Singletons have the disadvantage that everyone in the whole world has
access to that object, which is as bad as a global function. Anyone can
call a singleton and create havoc on it.
Singletons also introduce hard-coded dependencies that are difficult to
break if one wishes to change the environment or reuse some of the
classes in a different project.
Just because you call something a "singleton" instead of a global
variable does not make it a good pattern.
Singletons are lazy design, since "global scope" is too broad a scope
for most objects.
So my point is this: singletons should be discouraged, even banned.
Calum
- Next message: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Queries and OO"
- Previous message: JMF: "Re: Application, database and schema?"
- Next in thread: Daniel T.: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Daniel T.: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: smilemac: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Andrew McDonagh: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: H. S. Lahman: "Re: Singletons"
- Reply: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Thomas Gagne: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Thomas Gagne: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Doc O'Leary: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Ilja Preuß: "Re: Singletons"
- Maybe reply: Roger L. Cauvin: "Re: Singletons"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]