Re: Intellisense and the psychology of typing



On Fri, 27 May 2005 09:54:34 -0700, andrew queisser wrote:

>> Interesting reasoning, but I think it's flawed. Supposing a debate on
>> the subject were to occur, then we would likely get an uncountable
>> number of posts P1, P2, P3... Static analysis, however, informs us
>> that the sequence is non-convergent, and that this debate will not lead
>> to a conclusion, thus demonstrating the superiority of static analysis.
>>
> Don't forget Godwin's law. The hypothetical debate will have a countable
> finite amount of posts with no conclusion.

Not necessarily. Posts start to repeat but because the FSM's running in our
brains have a way lesser number of states than the number of possible PNs,
it could continue ad infinitum. [No I don't want to start that TDD debate
again! (:-))] Actually I don't trust in Godwin's law. Empirically, I'd
rather say that any USENET discussion has a period of half-life T. Now the
"true" law is:

the influence of your posting on T decreases exponentially with time

Somewhere around t=2T you can post virtually anything the discussion will
stop anyway!

--
Regards,
Dmitry A. Kazakov
http://www.dmitry-kazakov.de
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Barker up the wrong tree?
    ... you probably mistakenly see all his posts in the same ... a position of decency. ... but for how it hinders continuation of debate where such hindrance is ... its employees to publish a complaint made to them onto the internet. ...
    (uk.media.tv.misc)
  • Re: Youve got to be new sometime, no?
    ... Here's another "charming" thread from the FLASH board. ... Though it is so "awful" for us to post criticisms of what goes on over ... willing to debate in an "open forum." ... Or they can read all my posts rather than ...
    (sci.med.diseases.lyme)
  • Im back... What happened while I was away?
    ... SCI is like ground zero for the debate on the Israeli invasion of the Gaza ... WAY too many posts on that... ... I hope it's not just me that can put aside politics and see the person behind ... One last thing about neighbours... ...
    (soc.culture.irish)
  • Re: Has UKRS had its day?
    ... The number of monthly posts have declined in recent times. ... should spark a little more heated debate. ... that would make me cry out for a spam-free forum. ... Is UKRS in terminal decline? ...
    (uk.rec.scouting)
  • Re: Godel cant tell us what makes a mathematical statement true
    ... in this forum would be scorned by you, ... your past posts that seems to be the case. ... Sorry, but if you are going to engage in debate in an anarchic, public ... and it seems to me you consistently fail to see his point. ...
    (sci.logic)