Re: Let's put this to rest

"H. S. Lahman" <h.lahman@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:DCVjg.15224$OQ2.708@xxxxxxxxxxx

Responding to Perryman...

That is all there is to it. Do what you must in order to define the above
using "translation OOA" ...

You are asking for an OOP class definition, not an OOA model. Stick to
the original challenge and find an example in either book that you can
demonstrate would be done differently by "most people" because of some
fundamental difference in design methodology.

1. Already done. In a few seconds. No problem whatsoever.
So what I have is an OOA model for a stack.
Free of implementation info. Implementable in any way a developer sees fit.

2. I have chosen a trivial, well-known example.
But an example that IMHO will be done differently by people who use a
fundamentally different method.

Once we have gone beyond the trivial, I have what IMHO is a more
stimulating book example to play with.

But until then, my stack OOA model is ready and waiting. When yours is
ready,
inform me and we can post to comp.object to compare/contrast.


Regards,
Steven Perryman


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: OOA and OOD
    ... I think we have very different views of what a proper OOA model is. ... building an OOA model is a software design activity. ... >>least since UML added an abstract action language specification ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: Lets put this to rest
    ... find total number of oranges in the field... ... calling requirements analysis OOA. ... it appears the very core of our OOA models agreed in that example... ... you want an OOA model that is capturing some behavior too, ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: defining quality of OOA and OOD models
    ... and, consequently, the particular paradigm methodology. ... The exit criteria for OOD modeling is fuzzier ... functional and nonfunctional requirements and OOA focusing more on ... acid test of an OOA model is that it could be unambiguously implemented ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: OOA, OOD, design all first, how to go about it all?
    ... > either private or public. ... Public vs. private is not relevant at the OOA level. ... solution when the OOA model is completed. ... coding is now seamless cause of rigorous design. ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: OOA and OOD
    ... >> Requirements analysis is different than and done before OOA modeling. ... because the OOA model is a full executable solution for functional ... solution and to separate the customer space view of the solution ...
    (comp.object)