Re: Databases as objects

S Perryman wrote:
topmind wrote:

S Perryman wrote:

topmind wrote:

TM>I am only saying I don't challenge that domain.

1. No you are not. You stated :

"You guys often imply OO is Liquid Jesus, but offer ZERO evidence
outside of systems software."

That means people *have offered evidence* in that domain.

No, it does not. Saying, "There is no X outside of Y" is NOT the same
as claiming there is X inside of Y. You have committed a logical
fallacy.

Wrong. Because no one has said "There is no X outside of Y" .
You wrote :

"You guys often imply OO is Liquid Jesus, but offer ZERO evidence
outside of systems software."

Structuring the sentence as : X = evidence, Y = systems software

You guys often imply OO is Liquid Jesus, but offer ZERO X outside of Y

which suggests that greater than zero X is offered *inside* of Y.

In colloqial talk I suppose it could. But in a more literal or clinical
interpretion, it does not. Technically, it says NOTHING about the
innards of Y.

F8ck, man, why the hell don't you provide pro-OO evidence with this
much anal attention to detail??? It would be far more interesting.
He-said-she-said fights are yawners.



Otherwise you would have written : You offer zero evidence of OO being
better than <something> in any area.

Huh? Never mind. I am done with this train of thot.



2. Why do you not "challenge" that domain ??

Because I have insufficient experience in that domain. More specificly,
I cannot evaluate claims of change frequencies, which is a common theme
in these kinds of debates. If somebody says change A is more likely
than change B, I don't have the experience to question it and explain
in detail why it may be the other way around.

Well, once we know exactly what you have experience of working on, we
can debate accordingly.

I told you: mostly small and medium custom biz apps.



Regards,
Steven Perryman

-T-

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Databases as objects
    ... "You guys often imply OO is Liquid Jesus, but offer ZERO evidence ... Because I have insufficient experience in that domain. ... Steven Perryman ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: Databases as objects
    ... fallacy. ... You guys often imply OO is Liquid Jesus, but offer ZERO X outside of Y ... You offer zero evidence of OO being ... in these kinds of debates. ...
    (comp.object)