off-topic: Why is lisp so weird?

From: nobody (
Date: 02/29/04

Date: 28 Feb 2004 21:12:28 -0800

Howdy, Mike! (Mike Cox) wrote in message news:<>...
> I'm a C++ programmer, and have to use lisp because I want to use
> emacs. I've gotten a book on lisp, and I must say lisp is the ugliest
> looking language syntax wise. What is up with this: (defun(foo()).


> What were the lisp authors thinking? Why did Stallman use lisp in
> emacs so extensively?

C and C++ did not exist at the time. Do you think he should have used
Fortran for this? *shudder*

If someone, although not RMS, admittedly, was writing a new extensible
editor today, a combination of C++ and Python would have probably be

> Why oh why does such a weird and strange
> looking language end up in a major software package so now I have to
> learn it?

You can use better editors than Emacs. I'll give you a hint: no
12-finger key combinations with right clicking
and waving of a rubber wildebeest are happening in my office.

> My mind boggles at the craziness of lisp, and stallman's
> decision to add so much of it to lisp.

        "do not eval this inside omega-forms unless you know what you
are doing!"
           (HOPE I
                 (FEEL YOU (ADJECTIVE GOOD)))))

                 (USE (MAKE-SYMBOL "LISP")
                    :WHEN (PERIOD :FROM (YEAR 1982)
                                  :TO (YEAR 1991)))))

                 SEE YOU (ONLY (THE (CL::FIRST ICEBERG))))))

        ;; *shudder* is a special variable !

           (CAN YOU (USED GET (TO (THE (MANY PAREN))))
              :WHEN ,(LAMBDA (X) (> X (SEVERAL (MANY WEEK))))))

        ,(LET ((SURFACE T))
                  ((DOUBLE MUCHO) :CONTENT 'ATROCITY
                                  :WHERE? ,(LOCATION :TYPE


--> "I hope you feel better. As someone who used Lisp from 1982 to
1991, I feel your pain, but you have only seen the tip of the iceberg.
You can get used to the parens after a few weeks of using them a lot.
Larger atrocities are beneath the surface"

> If someone can answer my questions, I will spend less time with the
> emacs psychiatrist!

Just walk away and never look back, if you value whatever sanity you
have left in you, mate!


Relevant Pages

  • Re: IDE for Windows
    ... I'm very new to Lisp too, and while I don't have any really ... no free editor I found so far passes both tests. ... If all you think is good about Emacs is that it "indents Lisp ... In fact many Windows programmers put in more time learning editors ...
  • Re: Lisp at sexps length
    ... >> Hello, I've been watching some people learn lisp, and the sexp ... > typical GUI editor. ... In the Lisp example you'd change the actual code ... > In a similar way, Emacs is so ingrained into the Lisp psyche, it pretty much ...
  • Re: Good Lisp editor for Win
    ... i think Lars just says that "i cannot learn emacs" is not ...   -- i'd like to learn lisp. ... lisp editor, i want to use Java editor. ...
  • Re: New to common lisp, some non-technical questions
    ... Learning Emacs and SLIME is overkill until you are committed to master Common Lisp and you are working on sizeable projects. ... Emacs is a capable editor, but it takes much time and effort to learn how to use it effectively, and to configure it -- possibly along your keyboard -- for a smoother editing experience. ...
  • Lisp Celebrities and Computing History from Worse Is Better
    ... Lisp Celebrities and Computing History from Worse Is Better ... user program must be saved. ... invoked the system routine so that resumption of the user program ... especially involving lisp, emacs, unix. ...