GNU Public Licences Revisited (again)

So, what's the reasoning behind these licences that don't allow a commercial
(closed source) apps from using them?

In once sense, if the idea behind the GPL, etc. is to benefit others, this
is a limitation that will reduce the number of people that can actually
benefit from it. A closed source app is not going to open its source just
so it can use some GPL. If the source was allowed to be used by all,
without the restrictions on commercial apps, that would benefit a lot more
people, wouldn't it?

You'd have commercial apps integrating GPL stuff that people would buy if
they offered something that the free alternatives didn't offer. You have
all the free stuff, just as if the commercial app didn't exist (except that
you might have fewer users due to some of them prefering the commercial
alternative). You'd still have the open source 'community' that could
emulate the commercial app, if they wanted to.

I think if I were producing a commercial app and wanted to use some GPL, I'd
just write an open source wrapper around the GPL stuff and release the
wrapper so that commercial apps were allowed to use it - the wrapper might
be a bit of a dog to use though ;-) Would that layer circumnavigate the
restrictions?


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Interesting Web Site on Open Source Development
    ... And that is why many people refuse to work on GPL projects. ... And for most GPL apps (RosAsm certainly falls ... when i wrote the very first version of RosAsm Debugger: ... Public domain works great. ...
    (alt.lang.asm)
  • Re: Which Python web framework is most like Ruby on Rails?
    ... > It sounds like that's what Kent wants to do with the apps that he's ... > are based on GPL code. ... > affects Karrigell apps (apps that run under Karrigell and call ... Debian, for example, also holds to this interpretation and will ...
    (comp.lang.python)
  • Re: Interesting Web Site on Open Source Development
    ... This imply that the GPLed Apps have a very special status ... when i wrote the very first version of RosAsm Debugger: ... the GPL is the ony way to share between similar Projects. ... The sweat dreams of the Anti-GPL ass-holes are about to split ...
    (alt.lang.asm)
  • Re: GNU Public Licences Revisited (again)
    ... In once sense, if the idea behind the GPL, etc. is to benefit others, this ... A closed source app is not going to open its source just ... without the restrictions on commercial apps, that would benefit a lot more ... Then, it's up to your customer to decide, whetever or not he ...
    (comp.programming)
  • Re: GNU Public Licences Revisited (again)
    ... A closed source app is not going to open its source just ... > so it can use some GPL. ... > without the restrictions on commercial apps, that would benefit a lot more ... You'd still have the open source 'community' that could ...
    (comp.programming)
Loading