functions that halt

From: |-|erc (contactvia_at_wwwadamskingdom.com)
Date: 04/02/04

  • Next message: |-|erc: "Re: Complexity of refuting Turing machine impostors"
    Date: Fri, 2 Apr 2004 10:55:19 +1000
    
    

    There was a post in sci.math last year about the class of functions
    that are constructed upwards and are guaranteed to halt.

    How powerful would they be?

    There was no formal answer but the consensus was they would be trivial
    functions.

    Is this necessarily true?

    The halting proof started out as a system to check for errors in programs.

    We assume that 'programs' either halt or they don't (good assumption given
    our practices).

    >From that definition, no program can determine if a general function halts or not.

    But what if we assume all programs halt? This doesn't contradict the halting proof,
    merely denies its construction since it depends on an infinite loop being programmed.

    Herc

    --
     \          oo
       \____|\mn
        / /_/ /\ \_\
      / K-9/  \/_/   - www.YeOldeCoffeeShoppe.com -
    /____/_____\
    --------------
    

  • Next message: |-|erc: "Re: Complexity of refuting Turing machine impostors"

    Relevant Pages

    • Re: functions that halt
      ... > that are constructed upwards and are guaranteed to halt. ... What does "constucted upward" mean? ... "What if we restrict the class of programs to those ...
      (comp.theory)
    • Re: before Cantor there was Rantor
      ... >>halting proof is contradiiction of the existence of a particular defined ... halt function is a SPECIFIC function. ... I did disprove the Halting Proof. ... in that time then it outputs TRUE, otherwise it timed out and outputs DONTKNOW. ...
      (sci.math)
    • Re: before Cantor there was Rantor
      ... >>halting proof is contradiiction of the existence of a particular defined ... halt function is a SPECIFIC function. ... I did disprove the Halting Proof. ... in that time then it outputs TRUE, otherwise it timed out and outputs DONTKNOW. ...
      (sci.logic)
    • Re: Alan Turings halting proof is incorrectly formed PT Herc
      ... regarding HALT. ... Theoretical computer science is not concerned with this, ... >> This is not the halting problem, ... >> To say that the halting proof is incorrectly formed is a faulty ...
      (comp.theory)
    • Re: Alan Turings halting proof is incorrectly formed PT Herc
      ... regarding HALT. ... Theoretical computer science is not concerned with this, ... >> This is not the halting problem, ... >> To say that the halting proof is incorrectly formed is a faulty ...
      (sci.math)