Network Flow



I was posed with an interesting question for which I have no answer
yet. I post it here so that someone can have a try at it.

There is a directed, uncapacitated network with several source-sink
pairs (source and sink are distinct nodes). Each source-sink pair has
at least 2 simple paths (non-cyclic). Each flow through a path can take
positive, zero or negative value. We start with a network without any
flow (all paths carrying zero flow). Then arbitrary set flow on each
path (positive, zero or negative) such that the total path flows for
each source-sink pair sum up to zero. Assuming that all flows on a link
are additive regardless of where they originated from (or where they
destined to), prove that the resulting network cannot have all its
links carrying either non-positive only or non-negative only flows. In
other words, they must be one of the followings:
1) a mixture of positive, negative, and zero.
2) a mixture of positive and negative.
3) all zeros.

Note that the network is composed of directed links; meaning that each
link carries flow one directional only. A negative total flow on a link
does not mean the flow flowing in the opposite direction. It just means
the link is *indebt of flow*.

I've figured out a clue to start with: Observing that all links
carrying only non-negative flows, we can deduce that this is possible
only if there is some external flow has been injected into the network.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: TIG gas regulator scaling question
    ... >When gas flow is ZERO - where is the zero mark on the 'follow the bouncing ball'! ... Just turn off the gas. ... it is a Victor flow meter. ...
    (sci.engr.joining.welding)
  • Re: In IRR period in data flow compared to period in result percentage
    ... Don't insert blanks in cash flows that you use an IRR or NPV on!!! ... the last zero / positive / negative flow. ... It is imperative that the patches provided by Microsoft in its April Security Release be applied to Systems as soon as possible. ...
    (microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions)
  • Re: Current across the antenna loading coil - from scratch
    ... where the SWR meter does not exhibit current flow for this ... will read zero at a standing wave current node. ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: How to calculate the force ?
    ... Well, the plate is held transversal to the flow, presenting the most ... Flow is laminar, slope is ... zero. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Simulating simple electric circuits
    ... loads (which can signal change in current flow to the outside -- ... The calls traverse the network until they reach a "ground" object. ... the source passes a "telegram" instance with these ... to let load objects have a timer that resets their state to "no ...
    (comp.lang.python)