Re: Incremental search in vim Re: Great SWT Program



On Nov 1, 2:13 pm, Lasse Reichstein Nielsen <l...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Emacs is a GUI app in much the way an Edsel with cardboard wings glued
onto it is an aeroplane. :P

Nice joke, but you ignored the point.

That's because there was no point.

And the analogy holds quite well in fact -- those GUI ports of Unix
text-mode tools never have a proper GUI design; it's always apparent
that the GUI is a) an imitation of a Windows UI that, on close
inspection, is clearly not genuine and b) an afterthought to the
design rather than the app having been designed from the ground up to
be operated by a GUI.

Emacs is a GUI application in the same way Notepad is a GUI application.

Except in many ways that are important, such as the GUI conforming
completely to GUI-users' expectations regarding the semantics of
various widgets and behaviors ranging from scrollbars to selections.
They *never* quite get it right, because it wasn't written from the
ground up as a native Windows application, nor Mac, nor Java Swing.

Well, probably a little more, since Emacs can actually show images when
run on a display with that capability.

A cute hack, no doubt, but it does nothing to disprove the above.

[snip remainder including an implied insult]

None of the nasty things you imply about me are the least bit true.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Great SWT Program
    ... GUI to configure something. ... version of the configuration file. ... Is its design based pragmatically around ... stick shift with the groove pattern ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: very interesting survey of Tk vs. other toolkits
    ... Ease of distribution for Tk with Ruby isn't great... ... a modern GUI. ... GUI Design and programming are totally different ... same in every scripting language, except for tcl (and applescript, ...
    (comp.lang.tcl)
  • Re: VS2005 and VS 6.0
    ... design principles, but that's all old stuff anyway, and what good is it? ... Most of MFC is unchanged. ... Am I expected to re-learn the entire GUI? ... And how do I override the OnPaint function? ...
    (microsoft.public.vc.mfc)
  • Re: In phrase of LTC Spice
    ... Have you actually tried the SS GUI? ... improvements to the basic spice architecture was, arguable, one dude. ... If one was writing the *first* simulator ... board design simply plugs in already designed i.c.s. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: GUI designs, accessibility and navigability
    ... typists as there are so many great shortcuts available. ... But no single UI design can possibly be so adaptable - at least, ... Apple manuals never were much ... But then with a GUI you just dragged the files across ...
    (uk.comp.sys.mac)