Re: Question ?

Arne Vajhøj wrote:
"when compiler hits" is one of those terms, that I think the
native English speaking (or Germans that are exceptionally
good at English) should learn to live with.

Mark Space wrote:
I agree that some tolerance for non-native speakers is needed. At least it will improve the signal to noise ration in here. Endless pedantic grammar corrections benefit no one.

OTOH, people should know ...

John B. Matthews wrote:
This article expands on the topic and suggests a possible cause of what you observe:

<http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/determiners/determiners.htm>

There are two social forces influencing the discussion of English grammar in this group. Mark Space mentioned both - (in)tolerance and the pursuit of knowledge. Intolerance was really not the force at play in this thread.

Stefan Ram's highly technical discussion of the matter, and John B. Matthews' very informative reference, do not criticize but educate. They did not evince intolerance for the error, but discussed objectively and usefully a linguistic phenomenon that is relevant to this group precisely because of its international participation.

Arne's advice to be tolerant is, of course, fair and proper. It is clear that this particular instance, where very interesting information was politely presented with obvious intent to benefit everyone, falls within the guideline. I'm an American with a lifelong armchair interest in English grammar, and I found what Stefan and John presented new and fascinating.

--
Lew
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Interesting Unicef report
    ... :>: The New York Times style guide, for example, prefers Unicef ... John was the one who raised the issue ... Can't you comprehend simple English? ... I think that non-government schools would likely (as in so ...
    (rec.scouting.issues)
  • Re: How long doe it take to learn to read?
    ... John Holmes wrote: ... >>> In another ng a poster, in making an argument, made the rather ... >>> question is about learning to read not to read and write. ... medieval English speakers when it really ought to take five minutes to ...
    (alt.usage.english)
  • FS: Dr Who Key To Time R1 Boxset, Half Light (Demi Moore), Fat Actress S1 ++
    ... Special Features ... English ... Director Darrol Blake and Mary Tamm ... Tom Baker and John Leeson ...
    (uk.media.dvd)
  • Re: French pronunciation
    ... John> Yep, Cantonese has distinct central vowels, and I presume that ... English teachers (ranging from ones with bad ... British), mass media where the speakers speak (or ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: So-called rules
    ... but it is essentially no more than common sense. ... John Lawler is ... Real English has plenty of rules, but it's pretty much of a waste of time ... The reason why your "Jim is equally as strong as John" jars is not because ...
    (alt.usage.english)