Two questions about prog2

From: Spiros Bousbouras <spibou@xxxxxxxxx>
Date: Mon, 31 Mar 2008 08:35:50 -0700 (PDT)

1) The HS page on prog2 says:

prog2 evaluates first-form, then
second-form, and then forms,
yielding as its only value the primary
value yielded by first-form.

Is the last word meant to be "second-form"
instead of "first-form" ?

2) Is (prog2 form1 form*) the same as
(progn form1 (prog1 form*)) ?
.

Follow-Ups:
- Re: Two questions about prog2
  - From: Brian
- Re: Two questions about prog2
  - From: Geoffrey Summerhayes

Prev by Date: Re: (apply #'and '(t t nil)) not work
Next by Date: Re: Installing Portable Allegro Serve and sb-impl
Previous by thread: (apply #'and '(t t nil)) not work
Next by thread: Re: Two questions about prog2
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread

Relevant Pages

Re: How Common Lisp sucks
... intentionally deviate from the spec with no intention of fixing it when ... PROG2 is specified as being equivalent to PROG1. ... | yielding as its only value the primary value yielded by first-form. ...
(comp.lang.lisp)
Re: Two questions about prog2
... prog2 evaluates first-form, then ... yielding as its only value the primary ... value yielded by first-form. ... Is the last word meant to be "second-form" ...
(comp.lang.lisp)
Re: Two questions about prog2
... prog2 evaluates first-form, ... yielding as its only value the primary ... value yielded by first-form. ... Is the last word meant to be "second-form" ...
(comp.lang.lisp)
Re: CLHS bug? (PROG2)
... "prog2 evaluates first-form, then second-form, and then forms, yielding ... (Emphasis mine) ... Shouldn't PROG2 be returning the primary value returned by second-form? ...
(comp.lang.lisp)
Re: CLHS bug? (PROG2)
... "prog2 evaluates first-form, then second-form, and then forms, yielding ... (Emphasis mine) ... Shouldn't PROG2 be returning the primary value returned by second-form? ...
(comp.lang.lisp)