UI design for Tk app--PNG's or GIF's for icons?

I hope this isn't too off-topic. I'm curious as to what others think
about the question of gif or png files for icons in a Tk application.

I know gif's are more commonly used by Tk developers, likely because
gif's are supported natively and some de-facto Tk stock icons (such as
those that ship with BWidgets) are gif's. Other formats require the Img
extension.

Some say that png's look smoother than gifs, which can be jaggy, and
this may subtly contribute to user perceptions about an application's
polish. So: does anyone use png's in their applications? Or is this,
perhaps, more a matter of the overall application design/look/feel than
a single factor like the image format of the icons? (Looking at Eclipse,
where a huge amount of care has gone into the UI design and where the
icons are gifs, leads me to think that this is the case.)

--
Kevin Walzer
Code by Kevin
http://www.codebykevin.com
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: UI design for Tk app--PNGs or GIFs for icons?
    ... more a matter of the overall application design/look/feel than ... a single factor like the image format of the icons? ... icons are gifs, leads me to think that this is the case.) ... You may have seen some PNGs smoother than some GIFs, ...
    (comp.lang.tcl)
  • Re: UI design for Tk app--PNGs or GIFs for icons?
    ... about the question of gif or png files for icons in a Tk application. ... icons are gifs, leads me to think that this is the case.) ... No user will likely ever know or care what internal format you use for images. ...
    (comp.lang.tcl)
  • Re: show icon from .ico file in Word doc
    ... It sounds like what you need is what Graham suggested - if you don't have ... you can use SnagIt to *batch convert* icons to GIFs. ... Then just put the GIFs ... Word MVP web site http://word.mvps.org ...
    (microsoft.public.word.docmanagement)
  • More messed up icons
    ... computer and I'm having a few problems with icons, ... Most image files (JPEGs, ... GIFs, and BMPs to be exact) were associated with Microsoft Office ... leaving only the default icon image for all image files, ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Icon question/Silk
    ... but it seems to lack any icons other than 16x16. ... can still see it being useful for most applications, ... Kevin Walzer wrote: ...
    (comp.lang.tcl)